Skip to main content

Malice in Wonderland

As we gaze this week at the wonderland we call Congress, it might amaze us that Congress actually shut down the federal government over the implementation of the Affordable Care Act.

Rep. John Culberson of Texas grinned like a Cheshire Cat as he explained it this way in an outlandish interview on CNN, “we do not want the federal government socializing health care as they have in England and in France.”


This is socialized medicine?  Really?

He wasn’t content to leave it there, adding a new “sacred” right to the Constitution to explain further his position.

“The right to be left alone as Americans is probably our most important right.”

As the Mad Hatter would say, “Why, you might just as well say that ‘I see what I eat is the same as I eat what I see.’” 


He explained that he was invoking the memory of the 9/11 heroes who brought down the airplane in Pennsylvania that was headed to Washington.  Was the irony lost on Representative Culberson?  That plane was in all probability heading toward the Capitol, and the heroes who brought it down may not only have kept our government open that day, they may have saved Representative Culberson’s life, and the lives of many of his colleagues.

Meanwhile, as Representative Culberson – a House member since 2000 – was giving his interview, some really bad things were happening to Americans hoping for an end to the economic quagmire he helped to create.

The Dow was shedding 129 points in anticipation of the shutdown.  In the last week, U.S. companies lost about $200 billion in value – more than the combined value of every company in Poland.

And we have had to suffer through all this because giving a $6000 tax credit to families earning $50,000 per year who purchase their own private health insurance is too “socialist” for Culberson.

I believe in our government.  I believe it is there to protect our actual rights (not ones Representative Culberson invents) and to work toward the common good.

And I am bothered because there is no charity in Representative Culberson’s view, only malice.

Toward the people who are helped most by Obamamcare – people with serious mental illnesses and other chronic conditions, lower-income workers, and uninsured people, for sure.

And toward the President on a disturbingly personal level, too – because this shutdown is not really about debt or deficit either.

Does anyone really think that if Ronald Reagan – not Barack Obama – were to be magically transported down a rabbit hole to the presidency today, then Representative Culberson would be saying the same things?

Five years into Reagan’s presidency, our national debt, which would triple during his term, was up over 100 percent – more than it has grown during Obama’s presidency.  Our federal deficit had grown from $74 billion to over $212 billion.

Medicaid was being transformed from a mostly long term care program for elders to a safety net health insurance program for families.  By 1988, eligibility was increased to 185% of poverty for pregnant women and children and even more for some through the Katie Beckett waiver.  These are far more generous than the 138% of poverty level Obamacare established for adults with chronic conditions.

Before he left office, piled on top of all that debt, Reagan even proposed the bare outlines of much of what became the Affordable Care Act.

He asked Congress to include catastrophic insurance, limiting out-of-pocket costs to $2,000, for every American covered by Medicare – along with a $60 a year increase in premium to pay for it.  He proposed a federal/state partnership to promote the formation of state-based risk pools to provide insurance for those who could not obtain it.  He called on states to mandate enhanced employer-based health insurance coverage.  And in his February 1987 radio address calling for all of these things, he said that the federal government should work with the private sector to promote public education about the choices and options available.


Representative Culberson was serving his first term in the Texas House of Representatives in 1987.  Do you imagine he – one of only two sponsors of legislation to put Ronald Reagan’s image on the $10 bill- favored a government shutdown to prevent Reagan’s “socialized health care?”

Paul Gionfriddo via email: gionfriddopaul@gmail.com.  Twitter: @pgionfriddo.  Facebook: www.facebook.com/paul.gionfriddo.  LinkedIn:  www.linkedin.com/in/paulgionfriddo/

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

For the Health of Our Community, Can We Plan More in Advance?

Mayor Florsheim has proposed a budget with a 2.7 mill increase for the coming fiscal year. This will mean an increase in taxes of approximately $500 per year for a home with a market value (not an assessed value) of $250,000, with larger increases for many homes in our city. While I appreciate the time and effort that went into his budget calculation, like many people I don’t believe that this is a sustainable increase on top of the increases of the past few years. What I appreciate even more is that the Mayor has invited members of the public to work together to offer their own perspective and suggestions to the City Council. In the past few weeks, I have offered several short-term suggestions, including a job freeze, a search for an alternative health insurance provider, and greater advocacy at the state level for fairer PILOT funding for Middletown. As an example, the Mayor’s budget proposes $77,800 for a Grantwriter versus zero from the Finance Department. Maybe we wait on that? ...

Veterans and Mental Illness

On a sultry June morning in our national’s capital last Friday, I visited the Vietnam Veterans Memorial .   Scores of people moved silently along the Wall, viewing the names of the men and women who died in that war.   Some stopped and took pictures.   One group of men about my age surrounded one name for a photo.   Two young women posed in front of another, perhaps a grandfather or great uncle they never got to meet. It is always an incredibly moving experience to visit the Wall.   It treats each of the people it memorializes with respect. There is no rank among those honored.   Officer or enlisted, rich or poor, each is given equal space and weight. It is a form of acknowledgement and respect for which many veterans still fight. Brave Vietnam veterans returned from Southeast Asia to educate our nation about the effects of war and violence. I didn’t know anything about Post Traumatic Stress Disorder when I entered the Connecticut Legislature in the...

Trump, DC Homelessness, and the National Guard

Claiming that D.C. crime is out of control, President Trump has brought in the National Guard. Never mind that crime rates are down in the District. The optics are compelling. Trump blames homeless people. As Fox News reported , he is giving them two choices – jail or homeless shelters to treat mental health and substance use disorders. If these choices seem reasonable, they aren’t. Sending someone to jail who hasn’t committed a crime is a bad, even unconstitutional, idea. Like our new South Florida gulag, this notion offends many of us. And many, if not most, of the people who are chronically homeless have seriously undertreated mental health conditions. Jails and shelters don’t have the money or resources to provide that treatment. What this boils down to is comfort. Seeing homeless people congregating makes some people uncomfortable. President Trump is suggesting that the freedom to congregate peacefully is a freedom reserved only to some of us – not everyone. There’s bigotry t...