Our Health Policy Matters

It has been a busy health policy year.  Here are my choices for the top health policy stories.  They all may not have made big headlines, but all will reverberate for some time.  The Slowing of Healthcare Inflation This was on my watch list coming into this year , and I’ll lead with it today because it was the best health policy news of the year.  When healthcare inflation came in low this year, it did all sorts of good things.  It helped balance state budgets, extended the life of the Medicare Trust Fund, and dropped the price tag of the Affordable Care Act.  Inflation is supposed to jump up this year as millions more become insured, but we can at least hope that a more modest trendline continues. Mental Health Parity And for some more good news… It took five years and incessant lobbying from heroes like Patrick Kennedy, but the final rule implementing the Mental Health Parity Act of 2008 was finally released this year , coinciding roughly with the 50 th anniversa

At least thirty-six states increased funding for mental health services during 2013, according to a recent report by the National Alliance on Mental Illness .  And last week, Vice President Biden announced that the federal government was adding $100 million in new funding for mental health services. So have we turned the corner on our nation’s mental health funding crisis, as many of the accompanying news headlines seemed to imply?  Or are these initiatives more a token gesture aimed at mollifying the mental health advocacy community in the aftermath of the Sandy Hook massacre, as others have suggested ?  I think that – with a couple of notable exceptions in Connecticut and Texas – the initiatives tend more toward tokenism than real change. Consider the national initiative.  On the face of it, $100 million sounds like a lot of money.  But it still represents only around 3 percent of the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA) budget, the agenc

We hear so often that the Republicans have offered no alternatives to Obamacare that we think it must be true.  It isn’t.  They presented at least two alternatives to the Affordable Care Act in 2009.  And neither would be better than what we have today.  One would have had all the Obamacare implementation problems.  And the other would have insured no more than a thimbleful of people.  The first was called the Patients’ Choice Act, offered by Paul Ryan.  The other was called the Affordable Health Care Act for America, offered by John Boehner. Elements of the Ryan plan , which was introduced in the spring of 2009, will sound very familiar to you: “The federal government partners with states to create State Health Insurance Exchanges.” These exchanges became a core component of Obamacare, and would look exactly like the exchanges in place today. “The Exchange would require all participating insurers to offer coverage to any individual – regardless of age or

There are bad reviews and then there are bad reviews.  But it would be difficult to imagine some worse headlines than the ones Obamacare has received during the past month. My favorite for over-the-top headline?  How about this gem from the National Journal: “ Why Obamacare May Be Obama’s Katrina, Iraq .” That’s right.  An initiative to insure millions of Americans has been equated with the most frightening American natural and man-made disasters of the 21 st century.  In a world in which we have come to expect tight plotlines, heroic successes, and quick and satisfying endings, I imagine that a blockbuster like Obamacare was never going appeal to critics. The Obamacare story is being reported this month as if it were a classic disaster movie, with millions of people about to be left out in the cold to fend for themselves in a chaotic healthcare system as Obamacare exchanges crash and burn around them. But that’s not close to reality. This week’s announcement t