Skip to main content

Suicide and Obamacare

In 2009, there were 36,891 suicides in the United States, according to the CDC.  This translates to a rate of 11.9 for every 100,000 people.

And rates among certain groups were even higher.  For example, the suicide rate among veterans, according to the Veterans Administration, was three times higher – or 35.9 per 100,000 veterans.

Suicide is a problem that ought to command our attention.

And it does.  For many years we have used suicide data as surrogates for documenting the consequences of serious mental illness.  We all know that the “danger to self” standard we use for determining when people with mental illness qualify for emergency care is, in effect, a “suicide may be imminent” standard.

As a result, for many years community mental health organizations have also been asked to track suicides as a measure of the effectiveness of their programming. 

But there are reasons why focusing on suicide rates too closely leads to inadequate public policy.

Suicides are just the tip of the iceberg.

Many more people consider or attempt suicide than die from it.  If you really want to be staggered by a national statistic, CDC reported that in 2011 7.8 percent of the teenage population had attempted suicide.  That is one thousand times as many as had died from it.

Also, the overwhelming majority of people with serious mental illness who die early do so not because of suicide, but because they are undertreated for other chronic conditions (such nicotine addiction, diabetes, and cardiovascular problems).  Some of these are linked to treatments they receive for their mental illnesses.

Finally, at the community level the number of suicides is usually so small that it is nearly impossible for any single organization to affect the rate more than anecdotally.  The agency may be able to point to individual cases where its intervention made a difference, but it will probably never be able to move the rate on its own.

And when the suicide rates don’t move, policy makers use this to justify decisions to reduce or eliminate program funding. 

So what does Obamacare have to do with suicide?

Many other provisions of the law have been lost in the din surrounding the most visible parts of the Affordable Care Act.

One of these was a mandate that the Department of Health and Human Services focus on the quality of our health care.  Since 2012, it has been doing this, along with a number of agencies in the Department, including the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA). 

SAMHSA has just invested over two years in developing a National Behavioral Health Quality Framework (NBHQF)

When the NBHQF is finalized, it will open the door to the use of new standard outcome indicators in determining the effectiveness of health and behavioral healthcare in our communities. 

We will be able to add these indicators to suicide rates, giving state and local officials much more powerful tools in judging the effectiveness of community mental health programs.

For example, suicide risk assessments (NQF #0104) will become a standard diagnostic tool in provider settings.  Providers will also be expected to use depression screening tools such as the PHQ-9 at six and twelve month intervals to monitor patients consistently over time (NQF #0710-0712).  And risky behavior assessment and counseling for children under the age of 13 will become a standard of practice (NQF #1406), as will diagnostic evaluation of children with major depressive disorder (NQF #1364-1365).

These all focus our attention on the 999 in every 1000 who consider and attempt suicide in addition to the one who tragically commits it.

We can also expect the integration of health and behavioral healthcare to become more systematic. 

Cardiovascular and diabetes monitoring of people who are prescribed antipsychotics (NQF #1933-1934) will become a standard of practice, as will management of ADHD in children in primary care settings (NQF #0107-0108). 

These indicators focus our attention on some of the other reasons people with mental illness die so young.

We all have an opportunity to say how we feel about these indicators. 

SAMHSA has released the NBHQF in draft form, and is accepting public comments on it until September 17, 2013.  Comments can be submitted using an online form, and don’t have to be formal or comprehensive.

The NBHQF will be finalized after the public comment period.  Then it will begin to guide the funding and delivery of mental health services. 


But for the next week, we all can say how we think the government should measure the quality of our behavioral healthcare services.

Paul Gionfriddo via email: gionfriddopaul@gmail.com.  Twitter: @pgionfriddo.  Facebook: www.facebook.com/paul.gionfriddo.  LinkedIn:  www.linkedin.com/in/paulgionfriddo/

Comments

  1. You are right, Depression is main reason of suicide, because depression is a serious medical illness that involves the brain. It's more than just a feeling of being "down in the dumps" or "blue" for a few days. If you are one of the more than 20 million people in the United States who have depression, the feelings do not go away. and attempt the suicide. Thank you for sharing.
    ______________
    http://www.whywaitintheer.com/

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Veterans and Mental Illness

On a sultry June morning in our national’s capital last Friday, I visited the Vietnam Veterans Memorial .   Scores of people moved silently along the Wall, viewing the names of the men and women who died in that war.   Some stopped and took pictures.   One group of men about my age surrounded one name for a photo.   Two young women posed in front of another, perhaps a grandfather or great uncle they never got to meet. It is always an incredibly moving experience to visit the Wall.   It treats each of the people it memorializes with respect. There is no rank among those honored.   Officer or enlisted, rich or poor, each is given equal space and weight. It is a form of acknowledgement and respect for which many veterans still fight. Brave Vietnam veterans returned from Southeast Asia to educate our nation about the effects of war and violence. I didn’t know anything about Post Traumatic Stress Disorder when I entered the Connecticut Legislature in the late 1970s.   I had only vag

Scapegoats and Concepts of a Plan: How Trump Fails Us

When a politician says he has “concepts of a plan” instead of a plan, there is no plan. And yet, that’s where we are with Donald Trump, nine years after he first launched a political campaign promising to replace Obamacare with something cheaper and better, nearly four years after he had four years to try to do just that. And fail. Doubling down during Tuesday’s debate, he claimed he had “concepts of a plan” to replace Obamacare. Really? He’s got nothing. In fact, he sounds just like Nixon sounded in 1968, when he claimed he had a “secret” plan to get us out of Vietnam. That turned out to be no plan at all (remember “Vietnamization?”) and cost us seven more years there and tens of thousands of lives. The Affordable Care Act, about which I wrote plenty in this blog a decade or more ago, wasn’t perfect. But it was a whole lot better than what we had before it – and anything (save a public option) that has been proposed since. Back then, insurers could deny coverage because of pre-exi

The Missing Mental Health Element in the Ferguson Story

By now, everyone has heard the news from Ferguson, Missouri.  An unarmed 18 year old named Michael Brown was shot and killed by a police officer.  Michael Brown was black. Some of the events surrounding the shooting are in dispute.  But what isn’t in dispute is that for the past two weeks, a community has been torn apart by race – a community that until recently was best known for its proximity to St. Louis and its designation as a Playful City, USA . Picture credit: Health Affairs Media reports since the August 9 th shooting have focused almost entirely on one angle – race relations.  We’ve heard about unrest in the city, the National Guard, police in riot gear, and danger in the streets.  We’ve heard about the District Attorney’s ties to law enforcement, and concerns that a too-white Grand Jury may be racially motivated not to indict the police officer involved in the deadly shooting. But the media have been strangely silent about a different angle – this comm