Skip to main content

Posts

Showing posts with the label Obamacare

Why the Republicans Have No Health Care Plan

There's a simple reason why (after more than a decade) Donald Trump and the Republicans have no plan to replace Obamacare. I'll explain in a few minutes. But first, some background. When the Affordable Care Act (or Obamacare) was passed in 2010, it was an effort to expand health care coverage to a lot of people who needed it, while controlling their costs. It had certain key provisions, not the least of which were that people couldn't be denied coverage for pre-existing conditions, that all chronic diseases needed to be covered fairly, and lifetime coverage caps had to be lifted. The problem was that if you left matters to insurers to set insurance premiums based on what this would cost, the price of insurance would rise dramatically. So the government took a look at three different programs and ultimately put them together into one system. For people whose income was so low that they couldn't afford any real cost-sharing, the government expanded Medicaid. For elders...

Scapegoats and Concepts of a Plan: How Trump Fails Us

When a politician says he has “concepts of a plan” instead of a plan, there is no plan. And yet, that’s where we are with Donald Trump, nine years after he first launched a political campaign promising to replace Obamacare with something cheaper and better, nearly four years after he had four years to try to do just that. And fail. Doubling down during Tuesday’s debate, he claimed he had “concepts of a plan” to replace Obamacare. Really? He’s got nothing. In fact, he sounds just like Nixon sounded in 1968, when he claimed he had a “secret” plan to get us out of Vietnam. That turned out to be no plan at all (remember “Vietnamization?”) and cost us seven more years there and tens of thousands of lives. The Affordable Care Act, about which I wrote plenty in this blog a decade or more ago, wasn’t perfect. But it was a whole lot better than what we had before it – and anything (save a public option) that has been proposed since. Back then, insurers could deny coverage because of pre-exi...

The Better Care Reconciliation Act Isn't Better or Caring

I have at least two members of my immediate family who would be affected directly by the so-called Better Care Reconciliation Act (BCRA). It could cost them – and others like them – their money and their lives. The Senate bill released this week has two important improvements over the House American Health Care Act. First, like Obamacare but unlike the House version, it requires insurers to continue to offer coverage in the regular marketplace to people with pre-existing conditions. Second, it corrects a major flaw in the Affordable Care Act – as interpreted by the Supreme Court – by extending health insurance subsidies to everyone below poverty who is ineligible for Medicaid. Today, the poorest pay the same as the richest for health insurance, because the subsidies are limited to those between 100 and 400 percent of poverty. That’s the good news. But it all quickly unravels after this. Here are ten reasons why. First, while pre-existing conditions are cove...

The Better Care Reconciliation Act Isn't Better or Caring

I have at least two members of my immediate family who would be affected directly by the so-called Better Care Reconciliation Act (BCRA). It could cost them – and others like them – their money and their lives. The Senate bill released this week has two important improvements over the House American Health Care Act. First, like Obamacare but unlike the House version, it requires insurers to continue to offer coverage in the regular marketplace to people with pre-existing conditions. Second, it corrects a major flaw in the Affordable Care Act – as interpreted by the Supreme Court – by extending health insurance subsidies to everyone below poverty who is ineligible for Medicaid. Today, the poorest pay the same as the richest for health insurance, because the subsidies are limited to those between 100 and 400 percent of poverty. That’s the good news. But it all quickly unravels after this. Here are ten reasons why. First, while pre-existing conditions are cove...

Shhh. Don't Tell Ben Stein - ACA Didn't Reduce Access to Care, But AHCA Will

Did Obamacare reduce access to care? That’s one of the arguments being made today by members of Congress who have rushed to judgment by voting for an inadequate replacement plan. It may surprise you that they call it “AHCA,” which sounds just like “ACA.” But it shouldn’t. Polling data always showed that “ACA” was a lot more popular than “Obamacare,” because many people did not know they were the same thing.  Republicans are hedging their bets – next election they hope they can tell a confused public that they were opposed to Obamacare but for AHCA. But back to the question.  Did Obamacare reduce access to care? That’s the argument made by the American Spectator, which counts among its editors the conservative, math-challenged, icons Jeffrey Lord, Ben Stein, and Grover Norquist. They argue that this is evident because of the 71 rural hospital closures since 2010 – approximately one per month. That’s pretty astonishing. Seventy-one rural hospital closures i...

Shhh. Don't Tell Ben Stein - ACA Didn't Reduce Access to Care, But AHCA Will

Did Obamacare reduce access to care? That’s one of the arguments being made today by members of Congress who have rushed to judgment by voting for an inadequate replacement plan. It may surprise you that they call it “AHCA,” which sounds just like “ACA.” But it shouldn’t. Polling data always showed that “ACA” was a lot more popular than “Obamacare,” because many people did not know they were the same thing.  Republicans are hedging their bets – next election they hope they can tell a confused public that they were opposed to Obamacare but for AHCA. But back to the question.  Did Obamacare reduce access to care? That’s the argument made by the American Spectator, which counts among its editors the conservative, math-challenged, icons Jeffrey Lord, Ben Stein, and Grover Norquist. They argue that this is evident because of the 71 rural hospital closures since 2010 – approximately one per month. That’s pretty astonishing. Seventy-one rural hospital closures i...

Obamacare Repeal and Replace Measure Falls Short

The Affordable Care Act amendment offered by House leadership yesterday seems well-intended. But it falls far short of the “repeal and replace” promises that have been made for years. Instead of offering better health insurance, more choices, and greater affordability as promised, the draft proposal pushes more people into private health insurance exchanges, through which insurers will offer poorer coverage at a higher cost.  Older adults will immediately pay as much as 60 percent more for their health insurance. All individuals will find themselves subjected to a new “individual mandate,” disguised as a 30 percent premium surcharge for those who lose their coverage for more than two months and for those 26 year olds who fail to enroll as soon as they leave their parents’ policies. A new high risk pool for those with chronic diseases will become a multi-billion dollar unfunded mandate on the states by 2026. Employers will no longer have to provide insurance ...

Obamacare Repeal and Replace Measure Falls Short

The Affordable Care Act amendment offered by House leadership yesterday seems well-intended. But it falls far short of the “repeal and replace” promises that have been made for years. Instead of offering better health insurance, more choices, and greater affordability as promised, the draft proposal pushes more people into private health insurance exchanges, through which insurers will offer poorer coverage at a higher cost.  Older adults will immediately pay as much as 60 percent more for their health insurance. All individuals will find themselves subjected to a new “individual mandate,” disguised as a 30 percent premium surcharge for those who lose their coverage for more than two months and for those 26 year olds who fail to enroll as soon as they leave their parents’ policies. A new high risk pool for those with chronic diseases will become a multi-billion dollar unfunded mandate on the states by 2026. Employers will no longer have to provide insurance ...

Reforming Obamacare: What About a Per Capita Cap on Medicaid?

As Congress works through the challenge of changing Obamacare, how the federal government pays its share of Medicaid dollars will be part of the debate. At first, Medicaid was designed primarily to offer to people with chronic conditions the long-term care benefits that Medicare did not. It pays much of our nation’s nursing home bill.  It was later expanded to provide safety net insurance to low income families, especially for women and children. Medicaid is a federal/state partnership program. The states design their own programs within federally-established rules, and the federal government reimburses half (or more) of the state’s cost. The Affordable Care Act added a new wrinkle to the cost-sharing formula.  For those states that expanded the Medicaid program to serve even more people, including uninsured single adults, it offered 90+ percent reimbursement for the new populations.  To date, 32 states have expanded. What’s wrong with Medicaid? Medicaid costs...

Reforming Obamacare: What About a Per Capita Cap on Medicaid?

As Congress works through the challenge of changing Obamacare, how the federal government pays its share of Medicaid dollars will be part of the debate. At first, Medicaid was designed primarily to offer to people with chronic conditions the long-term care benefits that Medicare did not. It pays much of our nation’s nursing home bill.  It was later expanded to provide safety net insurance to low income families, especially for women and children. Medicaid is a federal/state partnership program. The states design their own programs within federally-established rules, and the federal government reimburses half (or more) of the state’s cost. The Affordable Care Act added a new wrinkle to the cost-sharing formula.  For those states that expanded the Medicaid program to serve even more people, including uninsured single adults, it offered 90+ percent reimbursement for the new populations.  To date, 32 states have expanded. What’s wrong with Medicaid? Medicaid costs...

Reforming Obamacare: The Challenge Ahead

President-Elect Donald Trump has suggested replacing Obamacare with a package of benefits that might include: Permitting Insurance to be sold across state lines Retention of the mandate covering pre-existing conditions Allowing young people to remain on parents’ insurance Creating high-risk pools to provide insurance to people with chronic diseases Using Health Savings Accounts (HSAs) as an alternative to tax credits Expanding the use of high-deductible plans to lower premium costs Let’s consider some of the challenges the President-Elect and Congress will face as they craft these – and other – provisions to amend the Affordable Care Act (ACA) .   Selling Insurance Across State Lines President-Elect Trump has been clear that he supports this idea, because it would bring more competition into state markets.  Here’s the challenge. Insurance is regulated by the states, and some states have tighter regulations than others. To allow insurance t...

Reforming Obamacare: The Challenge Ahead

President-Elect Donald Trump has suggested replacing Obamacare with a package of benefits that might include: Permitting Insurance to be sold across state lines Retention of the mandate covering pre-existing conditions Allowing young people to remain on parents’ insurance Creating high-risk pools to provide insurance to people with chronic diseases Using Health Savings Accounts (HSAs) as an alternative to tax credits Expanding the use of high-deductible plans to lower premium costs Let’s consider some of the challenges the President-Elect and Congress will face as they craft these – and other – provisions to amend the Affordable Care Act (ACA) .   Selling Insurance Across State Lines President-Elect Trump has been clear that he supports this idea, because it would bring more competition into state markets.  Here’s the challenge. Insurance is regulated by the states, and some states have tighter regulations than others. To allow insurance t...

The Climate Change in Insurance Exchanges

A different kind of climate change was in the news this week, as Gallup reported that the percentage of people who are uninsured declined rapidly from 17.1 percent to 15.9 percent in just three months. That is a pretty substantial drop, and one that began when people started signing up for Obamacare. According to Gallup and others, it translates into an additional 3 million people who now have health insurance, consistent with the numbers of people signing up for Affordable Care Act coverage. That’s good news for Obamacare – perhaps.  One of the more interesting – and sometimes frustrating – things about health policy is that like climate change it unfolds slowly over time, and so it is often difficult to see the change in climate while it is happening. For one thing, there are always other variables.  For example, the unemployment rate has also gone down during this period, from 7.2 percent last October to 6.7 percent today . It is possible that some o...

The Climate Change in Insurance Exchanges

A different kind of climate change was in the news this week, as Gallup reported that the percentage of people who are uninsured declined rapidly from 17.1 percent to 15.9 percent in just three months. That is a pretty substantial drop, and one that began when people started signing up for Obamacare. According to Gallup and others, it translates into an additional 3 million people who now have health insurance, consistent with the numbers of people signing up for Affordable Care Act coverage. That’s good news for Obamacare – perhaps.  One of the more interesting – and sometimes frustrating – things about health policy is that like climate change it unfolds slowly over time, and so it is often difficult to see the change in climate while it is happening. For one thing, there are always other variables.  For example, the unemployment rate has also gone down during this period, from 7.2 percent last October to 6.7 percent today . It is possible that some o...

Why Our Health Policy Matters More Than Ever in 2014

A single health policy issue will decide who controls Congress after the 2014 election.  Here’s why. You may have noticed the relative dearth of partisanship emanating from Washington over the past couple of months.  Congress approved a budget with little fanfare and passed a debt ceiling increase with no hint of strings attached. There is a reason for this newfound spirit of bipartisanship, and it is not what you think.  Congress isn’t suddenly taking to heart its relentlessly low approval ratings in 2013.  And it hasn’t just become aware of how unproductive it has been. Barring an unforeseen catastrophe like 9/11, Katrina, or Sandy, it’s just that members of Congress already know which issue will swing the upcoming election.  And they are not interested in muddying the waters at this relatively late date.  The Democrats know that they have an advantage in the improving economy, their stand on women’s issues, and their strong su...