The Ten Best and Ten Worst States for Your Mental Health

Connecticut spends four times more per capita on state mental health services than Texas.  In Florida, 25 percent fewer people report having mental illnesses than in Washington.

Across the nation, there are significant differences in the amounts states spend on mental health services.  Connecticut spends $189 per capita, while Texas spends only $39.

But there are also significant differences in the reported prevalence of mental illnesses.  For example, fewer than 18 percent of Floridians report having a mental illness during the past year, but in Washington almost 24 percent do.

But what happens when you put spending and prevalence together?  Some new rankings emerge that give you a measure of each state’s real commitment to protecting mental health – and treating mental illness – in their population. 

This week, I have ranked all fifty states using both spending and prevalence data.      

I have taken per capita mental health spending from Kaiser Family Foundation’s State Health Facts data, and prevalence data from SAMHSA’s Summary of the National Survey on Drug Use and Health (NSDUH).  Both data sets are from the 2010-2011 time period.

It turns out that some states spend more than ten times as much as others on behalf of people with mental illness.

You can no longer review the full list of the states because it was too dated.

But for now, if the commitment of state government is your measure, here were the ten best and ten worst states for your mental health in 2013.

The Best:

1. Maine.  Maine spends almost $1,900 per person with mental illness – 25 percent more than the next closest state.  It is tops in spending per capita, and but also 7^th best in percentage in percentage of people reporting mental illnesses.

2. Alaska.  Alaska is middle-of-the-pack in prevalence, but it is second in spending per capita.  The result?  Alaska spends just under $1,500 per person with mental illness.

3. Pennsylvania.  Pennsylvania is 3^rd overall in spending, but only 16^th best in prevalence.  That still results in spending of over $1,400 per person with mental illness.

4. New York.  New York is 4^th in spending, and middle-of-the-pack in prevalence.  It spends over $1,200 per person with mental illness.

5. Vermont.  Like New York, Vermont is 23 places higher in spending than in prevalence.

6. New Jersey.  New Jersey is 3^rd best in prevalence, but still spends over $1,100 per person with mental illness.

7. Arizona.  Arizona is only 36^th best in prevalence, but it invests well in mental health services, spending $1,044 per person with mental illness.

8. Connecticut.  Connecticut is one of eight states that spend at least $1,000 per person with mental illness.  It pays off for a state that is tied with Georgia for 9^th best in prevalence.

9. North Carolina.  North Carolina’s high ranking is driven by a 4^th best ranking in prevalence, and top twelve spending per capita.

10. Hawaii.  Balance is the key to Hawaii’s ranking – 15^th in prevalence and 10^th in spending.

And the worst:

41. South Carolina. South Carolina ranks 23^rd best in prevalence, but is 43^rd in spending.

42. Louisiana.  Louisiana is 35^th in prevalence, but it is not enough to nudge up its overall ranking.

43. Utah. Utah is 49^th in reported prevalence of mental illness – a surprise for a state that regularly ranks near the top in other health categories.  It spends only $263 per person with mental illness.

44. Kentucky.  Kentucky is middle-of-the-pack in prevalence, but spends only $259 per person with mental illness.

45. Georgia.  Georgia is tied with Connecticut for 9^th best in prevalence, but it by spends only one-quarter as much per person with mental illness.

46. Oklahoma.  Oklahoma earns its ranking by placing 40^th in prevalence and 45^th in spending.

47. Florida.  Florida ranks second in prevalence, but only 48^th position in spending per capita.  As a result, it spends just $222 per person with mental illness.

48. Texas.  Texas – which has the lowest prevalence of mental illness – still spends only $221 for each person with mental illness.

49. Arkansas.  Arkansas is one of only two states spending less than $200 per person with mental illness.  It is among the worst in both spending and prevalence.

50. Idaho.  Idaho is far and away the worst state for your mental health.  It is worst in reported prevalence and worst in reported spending.  How bad is Idaho?  At $143 per person, it spends less than one-tenth as much per person with mental illness as do Maine, Alaska, and Pennsylvania.

Paul Gionfriddo via email: gionfriddopaul@gmail.com.  Twitter: @pgionfriddo.  Facebook: www.facebook.com/paul.gionfriddo.  LinkedIn:  www.linkedin.com/in/paulgionfriddo/

Labels