Why Our Health Policy Matters More Than Ever in 2014

A single health policy issue will decide who controls Congress after the 2014 election.  Here’s why.

You may have noticed the relative dearth of partisanship emanating from Washington over the past couple of months. 

Congress approved a budget with little fanfare and passed a debt ceiling increase with no hint of strings attached.

There is a reason for this newfound spirit of bipartisanship, and it is not what you think. 

Congress isn’t suddenly taking to heart its relentlessly low approval ratings in 2013.  And it hasn’t just become aware of how unproductive it has been.

Barring an unforeseen catastrophe like 9/11, Katrina, or Sandy, it’s just that members of Congress already know which issue will swing the upcoming election.  And they are not interested in muddying the waters at this relatively late date. 

The Democrats know that they have an advantage in the improving economy, their stand on women’s issues, and their strong support among minorities.

The Republicans know that they gain support because of a still-too-high unemployment rate, unbalanced budgets and the increasing national debt, and an unpopular foreign policy.

But the issue that will swing the Congressional elections in November is the one in which the political advantage then is a little less clear today.  It’s Obamacare.  And that’s proof that our health policy matters more than ever in 2014.

The partisan Congressional lines are arguably drawn more sharply over Obamacare than any other public policy.  We all know of the dozens of party-line Obamacare “repeal” votes that have been taken in the House since its equally partisan passage in 2010.  No other issue comes close for purely partisan controversy.

So what might this mean in the fall?

The current generic Congressional ballot reflects a near dead-heat for the 2014 election, which (because of gerrymandering) would keep the make-up of Congress roughly as it is for another two years.  And the parties have been pretty even on the generic ballot since last October.

What happened in October was that the Democrats lost ground quickly when the initial Obamacare web site problems overwhelmed the news cycles for a month.

As a result, recent polling data suggest that Obamacare is less popular now than ever, with an unfavorability rating 12 points higher than its favorability rating as of February 15. 

From Republicans’ perspective, this is all they can hope for.  Obamacare is the issue that can protect the Republican majority in the House and give the party a fighting chance of picking up the Senate.  Republicans do not want to squander this opportunity by picking new fights they can’t win (and might even cost them their primaries) over deficits and debt ceilings in particular.  So they’ve stopped talking about these for now.

But the Democrats are standing pat because they’re betting that Obamacare will be much more popular in six months than it is today.

The reason is that we’re all beginning to see who is benefiting from the new law – people over the age of 55.

This is a high-voting constituency that went heavily Republican during the 2012 election.  Romney won the 45 to 64 year old demographic by 51-47 percent, and the 65+ demographic by 56-44 percent.

Ever since that election, people on Medicare have been enjoying free annual physicals and improved prescription drug benefits.  And they have not experienced the collapse of the Medicare system that some feared.

As it turns out, baby boomers are flocking to Obamacare, too.  According to one source, 31 percent of the new Obamacare enrollees are 55 years of age or older.  Until now, many of these people had no reason to vote for a Democrat this year.  They had lost their jobs and their insurance during the recession. But now they have insurance again.

Democrats are banking on the fact that they will not risk losing their insurance a second time by voting for a repealing Republican in 2014.

While most people may never understand Obamacare in its entirety, they are just beginning to understand how it affects them personally.  That’s ultimately what matters.

There may still be hand-wringing over fewer than 7 million Obamacare sign-ups this spring or too few young, healthy people in the exchanges, but that will just be background noise to actual voters in the fall. 

What will matter is what this election means for them personally, and that’s why Obamacare may still spring some November surprises.

Paul Gionfriddo via email: gionfriddopaul@gmail.com.  Twitter: @pgionfriddo.  Facebook: www.facebook.com/paul.gionfriddo.  LinkedIn:  www.linkedin.com/in/paulgionfriddo/