Skip to main content

Uninsured Numbers a Compelling Case Against States' Rights


“States’ rights” is as popular a rallying cry as ever as we enter the early stages of the 2012 election campaign. 

To advocates of states’ rights, they are code words for state innovation and initiative, unhampered by the demands of a federal government.   In their minds, we are a United States of America. 

To skeptics, we are a United States of America, and states’ rights are the code words of political leaders who want to run their states as fiefdoms and answer to no higher authority. 

The new 2010 uninsured numbers released by the U.S. Census Bureau last week make a compelling case against the states’ rights position.

In the South, where the drum roll for states’ rights beats most loudly, 19% of all people were uninsured 2010 for the entire year.  This was more than in the West, where 18% were uninsured, the Midwest, where 13% were uninsured, and the Northeast, where only 12% were uninsured.

Place clearly matters where health insurance is concerned, and innovation and initiative in providing coverage for health care take a back seat in the Mecca of states’ rights.

Geography is an important factor in determining insurance status, but it isn’t the only one.  Others include:

·         Race and ethnicity – 31% of Hispanics were uninsured for the entire year, as were 21% of blacks;

·         Immigrant status – 34% of all foreign-born U.S. residents were uninsured, including 45% of those who are not citizens and 20% of those who are;

·         Income – 27% of people in households with less than $25,000 per year were uninsured.

But as bad as these numbers look, what’s behind them in the more detailed tables that accompanied the Census Bureau release is worth examining. 

It isn’t race, immigrant status, or income driving the health insurance numbers.  It’s geography.

Consider this fact.  The news headlines reported that 16.3% of the population of the United States as a whole was uninsured.  But when you remove people over the age of 65 – who are almost universally insured through the federal Medicare program – the percentage rises to 18.4%.

But in the two biggest southern states of Florida and Texas – where the new leaders of the states’ rights movement sit in Governor’s chairs – the numbers are far worse. 

In Florida, 24.6% of all people under the age of 65 were uninsured in 2010 for the entire year.

In Texas, 26.9% of all people under the age of 65 were uninsured in 2010 for the entire year.

Florida has earned its states’ rights badge through Governor Rick Scott’s attack on the Affordable Care Act.  His administration has refused to implement its consumer protections.  He has famously refused to accept public funding for many needed services because the funds were associated with the Act.  And he has turned down dollars to set up a health insurance exchange that would make more privately-funded insurance available in the state, too. 

Texas has earned its badge through Governor Rick Perry’s attack on Medicaid.  He has advocated repealing the Medicaid program in its entirety, making Medicaid a block grant so that Texas can do whatever it wants with it.  He once suggested seceding from the union if he didn’t get his way.

The one thing that neither Rick Perry nor Rick Scott can do is blame the federal government for the failures of their states to insure their populations properly.  Nor can they blame racial, ethnic, immigration, and income factors.

Mississippi, South Carolina, Maryland, and Georgia all have higher percentages of African Americans than Texas and Florida, but lower percentages of uninsured people.  New Mexico has a higher percentage of Hispanics than Texas, but a lower uninsured percentage.  And California has more undocumented immigrants than Texas and Florida combined, but a lower uninsured percentage, too.

Florida and Texas are also by no means the poorest states in the union. 

Florida and Texas have reached the bottom of the uninsured barrel through their own policy actions and despite their considerable assets.

When their governors talk about states’ rights in the area of healthcare, they seem to be arguing that every state should aspire to their level of failure.

Meanwhile, the one thing everyone seems to agree on is that more people in Texas and Florida will become insured when the Affordable Care Act is implemented by the federal government in a little over two years.

This has been characterized in recent Presidential debates as a federal takeover of health insurance.  But does anyone seriously believe that we would ever have needed an Affordable Care Act – or that it would have passed – if every state, including Texas and Florida, had taken care of its own problem like Massachusetts did?  

In Massachusetts, only 6% of the population was uninsured in 2010.

If you have questions about this column, or would like to receive an email notifying you when new Our Health Policy Matters columns are published, please email gionfriddopaul@gmail.com.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Veterans and Mental Illness

On a sultry June morning in our national’s capital last Friday, I visited the Vietnam Veterans Memorial .   Scores of people moved silently along the Wall, viewing the names of the men and women who died in that war.   Some stopped and took pictures.   One group of men about my age surrounded one name for a photo.   Two young women posed in front of another, perhaps a grandfather or great uncle they never got to meet. It is always an incredibly moving experience to visit the Wall.   It treats each of the people it memorializes with respect. There is no rank among those honored.   Officer or enlisted, rich or poor, each is given equal space and weight. It is a form of acknowledgement and respect for which many veterans still fight. Brave Vietnam veterans returned from Southeast Asia to educate our nation about the effects of war and violence. I didn’t know anything about Post Traumatic Stress Disorder when I entered the Connecticut Legislature in the late 1970s.   I had only vag

Scapegoats and Concepts of a Plan: How Trump Fails Us

When a politician says he has “concepts of a plan” instead of a plan, there is no plan. And yet, that’s where we are with Donald Trump, nine years after he first launched a political campaign promising to replace Obamacare with something cheaper and better, nearly four years after he had four years to try to do just that. And fail. Doubling down during Tuesday’s debate, he claimed he had “concepts of a plan” to replace Obamacare. Really? He’s got nothing. In fact, he sounds just like Nixon sounded in 1968, when he claimed he had a “secret” plan to get us out of Vietnam. That turned out to be no plan at all (remember “Vietnamization?”) and cost us seven more years there and tens of thousands of lives. The Affordable Care Act, about which I wrote plenty in this blog a decade or more ago, wasn’t perfect. But it was a whole lot better than what we had before it – and anything (save a public option) that has been proposed since. Back then, insurers could deny coverage because of pre-exi

Anxiety and the Presidential Election

Wow. Could the mainstream media do anything more to raise our anxiety levels about the 2024 election? And diminish or negate all the recent accomplishments in our country? Over the past three-and-a-half years, our nation’s economy has been the strongest in the world. Unemployment is at record lows, and the stock market is at record highs. NATO – which last came together to defend the United States in the aftermath of 9/11 – is stronger than ever. Border crossings are down. Massive infrastructure improvements are underway in every state. Prescription drug costs are lower. We finally got out of Afghanistan – evacuating more than 100,000 U.S. citizens and supporters – with just a handful of deaths. Inflation – which rose precipitously in the aftermath of the pandemic – has come back down, and prices in many areas have even begun to decline. And yet, all the media commentators can talk about these days – and they are not “reporters” when they are clearly offering opinions to frame the